SAP vs Oracle vs AX

Posted by Alvin You
2013.10.13 23:41 Dynamics AX

Welcome to the ERP Fight Club:

In Today’s match let me introduce you with our fighters:
1.)SAP
2.) Oracle(E-Business Suite)

3.) Microsoft (Microsoft Dynamics)

4.) Other ERP vendors.

Each of these has their own advantages and disadvantages. So to get the clear idea we will compare all of these according to different points. Starting with

1.Market Share:

 

So i think SAP is leading the way in this Game.

2.Average ERP Solution Satisfaction and Benefits Realization.

According to survey carried out over thousands of companies which use the ERP Tools.

SAP Gives : 75%

Oracle Gives : 60%

Microsoft Gives : 58%

Other ERP Vendors gives : 60%

 

So again SAP wins the game. The biggest advantage with SAP is the huge experience which it gets from its client and makes the ERP Tool more Power full to satisfy each and every business need.

3.Average Cost to maintain and implement the ERP Tool

SAP : $16 M

Oracle : $12 M

Microsoft :$3 M

Others : $3.5 M

 

if you don’t want to spend much for ERP tool just go for the last two options.

4.Average implementation Time Duration :

SAP : 15 Months

Oracle : 13 Months

Microsoft : 12 Months

Others : 11 months

5.Business Risk Factor:

This factor is most important as it gives the proportion of the companies that suffered from operational interruptions following go-live are relatively high.

저작자 표시
신고
이 댓글을 비밀 댓글로

AX VS SAP?

Posted by Alvin You
2013.10.12 01:00 Dynamics AX

Dynamics AX 업계에 종사하면서 SAP 시스템과의 차이점에 대해서 고민하지 않으면 안 될 것 같아, 외국 친구들 중에 나와 비슷한 고민을 하는 사람은 없을까 해서 Google 검색을 해봤다.

아래 답변 내용은 Dynamics User Group이라는곳에서 누군가 AX VS SAP? 이라는 질문에 답변을 단 내용을 원본 그대로 가져온 내용이며, 찾아본 내용 중 가장 괜찮은 답변 같아 이곳에 옯겨놨습니다.

Hi

My company left SAP R3 for AX 2009 since 2008, I would say SAP is good for large companies but doesn't fit to middle-sized and small companies.

In terms of integration and implemantation, SAP is really heavy. and rustic, works on HP UX for me with text administration console for the database. An advantage, SAP is very stable and in my case had a better SGBD (Oracle 10) than SQL Server 2005 with AX. An other advantage, the financial and accounting module is better in SAP, a lot of things are automated,

My personnal point of view about development : there's no possible comparison, SAP is a frozen environnment, extremely complicated even if you want to do small visual customization as change labels in forms. AX is very flexible,has a simple and efficient development interface, the X++ language is easy to learn ( most like C# and java) once you have a small development experience and if you have skilled developpers, you can do just about what you want.

In summary, AX is more flexible and you can customize yourself your environment and adapt the processes to your company activity. you can do much more by yourself than in SAP which oblige to deal with external services providers but is more stable and efficient on a few processes. the cost aspect depends on your retailor but SAP is expensive, much more than AX.

About careers, I'm located in the country-sided France, so it's complicated but in large cities like Paris, for example, there's a lot of AX opportunities

You can mail me if you have precise questions

Regards,

Thomas

원본 위치 : http://dynamicsuser.net/forums/p/53651/281135.aspx

 

신고
Tags
이 댓글을 비밀 댓글로